With so much media attention focused on drug violence in Mexico, many potential tourists and tour operators are canceling planned trips to Mexico. Are such decisions rational? The analysis below indicates that travel to Mexico is considerably safer than risking vehicle traffic in the USA.
The US State Department has issued numerous travel advisories concerning visits to Mexico. As we discussed in a previous post —Which parts of Mexico are currently subject to US travel advisories?— the advisories focus on specific areas of Mexico. Unfortunately, many potential tourists overlook the geographic specificity and get the impression that all parts of Mexico are dangerous. Previous posts clearly indicate that levels of drug war violence vary enormously from place to place in Mexico.
- Is drug war violence concentrated in Mexico’s largest cities?
- The rates of drug war deaths vary enormously in Mexico’s states
This post investigates the chances of being a fatal victim of drug violence in various places in Mexico and compares these with the chances of being a fatal victim of a traffic accident in the USA. The US Department of Commerce estimates that about 19 million US citizens visit Mexico each year. According to MSNBC, in 2010 at least 106 Americans were killed in Mexico as a result of drug violence. Dividing the 19 million visits by the 106 deaths suggests that the chance of a visitor being killed on a trip to Mexico in 2010 was about 1 in 179,000. These are good odds, much better than the annual chance of being killed in a US traffic accident which is about 9,000 to 1. In other words, the chances of dying in a US traffic accident are roughly 20 times greater than being killed as a consequence of drug violence while visiting Mexico. (As an aside, the annual chances of being killed in a Mexican traffic accident are about 1 in 4,800.)
Chance of a visitor being killed in drug violence in Mexico Relative danger of death in a road accident in the USA
MEXICO (whole country) 1 in 179,000 20 times greater
Ciudad Juárez 1 in 11,400 1.3 times greater
State of Chihuahua 1 in 18,500 2.1 times greater
Culiacán 1 in 25,000 2.8 times greater
Mazatlán 1 in 47,000 5.2 times greater
Tijuana 1 in 52,000 5.7 times greater
Monterrey 1 in 210,000 23 times greater
Puerto Vallarta 1 in 288,000 32 times greater
Chapala 1 in 299,000 33 times greater
Cancún 1 in 360,000 40 times greater
State of Jalisco 1 in 378,000 42 times greater
Oaxaca City 1 in 427,000 48 times greater
Guadalajara 1 in 569,000 63 times greater
Mexico City 1 in 750,000 83 times greater
State of Yucatán 1 in 4,151,000 460 times greater
Puebla City 1 in 6,572,000 730 times greater
Some areas of Mexico experience much more drug violence than others. For example drug violence deaths in Ciudad Juárez are 16 times greater than the Mexico national average. Consequently, the chance of an American visitor getting killed in drug violence in Ciudad Juárez is about 11,400 to one, still safer than risking traffic in the USA. The table shows the risks for a range of Mexican locations and compares them to the risks of US traffic. In the city of Puebla the risk is one in 6.6 million compared to one in 750,000 for Mexico City, one in 570,000 for Guadalajara, one in 360,000 for Cancún, about one in 300,000 for Chapala and Puerto Vallarta, and about one in 50,000 for Tijuana and Mazatlán.
These results indicate that the chance of a visitor being killed by drug violence in Mexico is extremely unlikely, far less likely than the risk of being killed in a US traffic accident. For example, a visit to Chapala is 33 times safer than risking US traffic for a year, while Mexico City is 83 times safer. Though this analysis focuses on the travel of US tourists to Mexico, the results are equally relevant for visitors from other countries.